A utilitarians point of view on compulsory vaccination

The Issue of Our Times. The Social Responsibility of Health Professionals: N Engl J Med ; 6: This can involve prevention measures such as the use of compulsory vaccinations to reduce harm in individuals.

Ethical Issues in Modern Medicine. All societies have a shared vulnerability to emergencies, although poor societies are more severely devastated because poverty undermines resilience. Epidemiological data have shown that HPV is a common sexually transmitted infection in the United States.

When it comes to vaccination, utility is fortunately often greatest when the most socially disadvantaged groups are targeted. According to the duty of care based on the principle of beneficence, governments must make vaccines available against the most contagious diseases.

Ethical considerations for vaccination programmes in acute humanitarian emergencies

J Child Psychol Psychiatry ;45 2: It erroneously assumes that all humans are equal. Bayer and Moreno point out that the Court in this case decided that a compulsory vaccination program that addressed a smallpox outbreak was legal.

Sex Transm Dis ;26 suppl 4: Abstract Compulsory human papillomavirus HPV vaccination of young girls has been proposed as a public health intervention to reduce the threat of the disease.

Scientific observations have documented that young people in the United States engage in sexual practices that place them at risk for STIs and subsequent illnesses such as cervical cancer.

Making age, marital status, or sexual activity a criterion for receiving health care is discriminatory. These stakeholders may have conflicting priorities and motives, which contributes to various ethical discussions.

Oxford University Press; In scientific experiments designed to find ways to cleanse the German state of all infection of it by individuals the state had decided harmed the public good, including physically and mentally handicapped children and adults as well as those suffering from serious diseases, physicians and public health officials played a leading role.

J Sex Res ; But youths who face the threat of STIs and cancer are in as great a need of disease prevention as children who faced the threat of polio in the s.

Utility can conflict with equality or fairness. On the other hand, vaccination is sometimes contraindicated or inappropriate. The World Publishing Company. For instance, TB vaccine researchers have struggled to devise ethical control group procedures.

Free association.

Guidelines are especially valuable in certain situations: Finally — to reiterate As already mentioned, in all cases, an empathy-based compassionate ethic should be applied where appropriate. However, the argument becomes invalid if vaccination during an acute humanitarian crisis can provide immediate protection against serious illness or death.

Department of Health and Human Services. Religious groups oppose mandatory HPV vaccination. Implicit in the concept of informed consent is the right to refuse consent or, in the case of vaccination laws, the right to exercise conscientious, personal belief or philosophical exemption to mandatory use of one or more vaccines.

During the consent process, study participants need to be made aware that they are consenting to research only, not to special or additional care. Research protocols should be relevant, methodologically sound and explicit about the benefits and potential harms to study participants.

We maintain this is a responsible and ethically justifiable position to take in light of the fact that vaccination is a medical intervention performed on a healthy person that has the inherent ability to result in the injury or death of that healthy person.

Katz said that the judges of the Nuremberg tribunal, overwhelmed by what they had learned, "envisioned a world in which free women and men, after careful explanation, could make their own good or bad decisions, but not decisions unknowingly imposed on them by the authority of the state, science, or medicine.

These range from mild, common reactions, such as inflammation and pain at the injection site, to more severe but extremely rare events. American Social Health Association Panel.You have the right not to be exposed to certain diseases that could be prevented by vaccinations that have long been determined to be safe.

If you are a business, you can refuse to hire non-vaccinated employees, for example. If you are a hospital, or doctor, you can demand vaccination as a condition of service. Whether a vaccine damages one in ten thousand or 1 in ten million children or a single child, that makes authorities morally obligated to not make vaccinations compulsory for all.

Thus, utilitarianism – the awful pseudo-ethic for “justifying” mass vaccination as public health law and policy needs to be banished. A Utilitarian's Point of View on Compulsory Vaccination PAGES 3. WORDS View Full Essay.

More essays like this: Not sure what I'd do without @Kibin Sign up to view the complete essay. Show me the full essay. Show me the full essay. View Full Essay. This is the end of the preview. Research must be distinguished from disease and programme surveillance. 47 Surveillance is essential for assessing vaccination coverage, informing programme planning, evaluating vaccine effectiveness, and monitoring safety in the population as a whole and in certain subgroups.

48 Surveillance also allows the rapid detection of. Although vaccines can help prevent these diseases, vaccine development lags behind community health needs.

[1] To further complicate matters, the places affected by poverty diseases often lack the infrastructure to support wide-scale vaccination, and face many competing health and social priorities, such as poverty, violence, and poor roads. vaccinations, even when parents or individuals refuse vaccinations?

Do the benefits of vaccina-tions for public health justify overriding individual liberty and autonomy? CONTENTS 1.

The Moral Justification for a Compulsory Human Papillomavirus Vaccination Program

Introduction to Topic 2. Vaccines in the Media 3. Vaccine Laws in the United States 4. Religious Perspectives on Vaccines 5. The Modern Philosophical .

A utilitarians point of view on compulsory vaccination
Rated 0/5 based on 96 review